Skip to content

James Still dismissed from EMU basketball team

November 16, 2012

After EMU issued their statement earlier today announcing that James Still was suspended from the men’s basketball team following his guilty plea, the Detroit Free Press ran an online article questioning whether EMU was following their Student-Athlete Discipline Policy. Relevant parts of the policy follow, with emphasis added:

Any student-athlete charged with a felony, or with a crime involving gambling or game fixing under Michigan law or any other jurisdictional equivalent, shall be suspended automatically from practice and playing privileges until the charges are dropped, dismissed or otherwise resolved. The student-athlete may appeal this decision pursuant to the Appeals Procedure outlined in this policy.

Any student-athlete convicted of or pleading no contest to a felony charge or a gambling or game fixing charge under Michigan law or any other jurisdictional equivalent shall be permanently dismissed from the team. The student-athlete’s right to retain his/her grant-in-aid for the remainder of the academic year will be determined on a case-by-case basis. The Department of Athletics shall recommend nonrenewal of the scholarship to the Office of Financial Aid for any succeeding academic years. The student-athlete may appeal this decision pursuant to the Appeals Procedure outlined in this policy.

Four hours later, EMU released an update, citing this policy, indicating that Still has now been dismissed from the team. That update follows in full.

The Eastern Michigan University Department of Athletics policy on student-athlete discipline states the following: “Any student-athlete convicted of or pleading no contest to a felony charge or a gambling or game fixing charge under Michigan law or any other jurisdictional equivalent shall be permanently dismissed from the team.”

Accordingly, James Still is dismissed from team activities. The student-athlete discipline policy allows for an appeal process should the student athlete so choose.

Federal privacy regulations prevent the University from speaking specifically to the situation involving Mr. Still’s admission to the University. However, EMU takes the safety of its campus seriously and has an admissions process that balances the safety and security of campus with the goal of providing an opportunity to individuals who have made mistakes in the past.

A student who indicates that they have criminal charges pending against him or her is not automatically precluded from admission to the University. An Admissions Review Board reviews their application and makes a determination regarding admission.

All I can think is that whoever was handling this at EMU forgot their own policy until the Freep was so kind as to remind them. As to the comments about admission standards and privacy regulations, I don’t know that  anyone has questioned Still’s admission to EMU. What is being questioned is why, having an open felony charge against him, Still was recruited by Murphy, offered an athletic scholarship, and allowed to join the men’s basketball team, in spite of a clear policy to the contrary.

7 Comments leave one →
  1. Mark Higbee permalink
    November 17, 2012 6:45 am

    Very good posts, cmadler. It appears to be another instance of EMU officials forgetting that official actions should be governed by policy and principle. How many officials were in open violation of the policy, which is designed to protect the people on campus as well as the university’s reputation? Your last sentence — “What is being questioned is why, having an open felony charge against him, Still was recruited by Murphy, offered an athletic scholarship, and allowed to join the men’s basketball team, in spite of a clear policy to the contrary” — shows how shameful and needless this episode was.

    • cmadler permalink*
      November 17, 2012 4:37 pm

      The word from everyone at EMU is, and continues to be, “No comment.” As Jeremy mentioned, we’re going to keep following up on this one.

  2. Chief Huron permalink
    November 18, 2012 10:13 am

    Another wonderful performance from our AD Gragg, now we need to rely on a newspaper to tell us what our policies are?

  3. grady permalink
    November 19, 2012 1:01 pm

    Great work guys – this blog is the only place one can read insightful, accurate and detailed coverage of EMU athletics – I wish annarbor.com would just give up and sub contract you guys to cover EMU … they ran a freaking AP story about EMU this weekend (WMU game). Think about it – all the EMU road games were in Michigan, Ohio, Indiana and one in Illinois and they cant send a reporter to cover the games and can barely manage home game coverage.

  4. cmadler permalink*
    November 19, 2012 4:44 pm

    Yeah, I was sitting next to the empty AnnArbor.com seat in the WMU pressbox. Almost took a picture of it for a laugh…maybe I should have!

Trackbacks

  1. James Still dismissed from Eastern Michigan basketball team | BallinMichigan
  2. Three EMU Football Players Charged with Assault - Eagle Totem Eagle Totem

Leave a Reply